Case study (Offside offence)

歡迎各位分享你的裁判執法技巧

版主COLON 版面管理員

頭像
cyhenry
文章COLON 102
註冊時間COLON 09年9月6日20:45 週日

Case study (Offside offence)

文章cyhenry » 11年9月10日23:39 週六

Just watch the match South China vs Tuen Mun, I found a question that I can't answer myself after a period of time to condense.

My question is about the visitor's second goal, there's no doubt the scorer isn't offside, however, there's one more TM player is in front of goal and he is in somewhere close to the flight of the ball.

According to my knowledge of the LOTG, I remember if a player is able to affect the judgement of the his opponent's GK, it is also a kind of offside offence. Is there any misconception by me?

Another question carried out in the same match is tackling from behind. I count this a complicated question as the degree of punishment can be determined by the offending player's attitude, whether the force are excessive, etc. On the 78th minute, Nikola of Tuen Mun fouled Leung Chun Pong of South China from his behind. Clearly, there's no sense for the Serb to reach his leg to the ball but to stop the counter attack and harm the player instead. At the first instant, i thought it was a red one, but to my surprise, it's a booking.

I am not having doubt on anyone's ability, but just share something.
確實是誰被判罰了 也是有異聲

ahsir
文章COLON 23703
註冊時間COLON 03年11月9日23:12 週日

文章ahsir » 11年9月12日08:30 週一

:smt003

文章有深度、值得一讚,但無看球賽....
:smt006

colour
文章COLON 480
註冊時間COLON 06年4月11日01:37 週二

文章colour » 11年9月14日23:53 週三


頭像
cho cole
文章COLON 26158
註冊時間COLON 03年11月5日18:58 週三
來自COLON HKFRA
CONTACTCOLON

文章cho cole » 11年9月14日23:55 週三

I am sorry I am AR 1 in this match have no comment bcz two cases far from me
If we can see the clip later from now TV discussion with you again
cho cole
Keep strong never give up

ahsir
文章COLON 23703
註冊時間COLON 03年11月9日23:12 週日

Re: Case study (Offside offence)

文章ahsir » 16年5月4日13:36 週三

:smt033

昨馬體会1 - 1 那球似越位, AR位置明顯不 level with 2nd
last defender , not convincing ....

:smt017